A potential $300 million annual royalty loss for American recording artists and labels in Europe now hangs over the stalled American Music Fairness Act, transforming a decades-old copyright defect into an urgent trade discrimination crisis. On July 8, a rare coalition spanning performers, independent labels, unions, songwriters, and the Recording Academy warned U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer that the European Commission may abandon “national treatment” to impose “material reciprocity,” withholding royalties from U.S. creators because American AM/FM radio does not pay them [source].
The $300 Million Trade Threat
The coalition’s letter identifies a specific mechanism for economic retaliation: if Europe shifts from national treatment to material reciprocity, it would legally permit the withholding of royalties generated by American recordings based on the U.S. failure to pay performers for terrestrial radio broadcasts [source]. Under current international copyright principles, American artists receive the same compensation European countries give their own creators when their music is broadcast overseas [source]. The proposed European policy would reverse this, allowing broadcasters to pay royalties that simply do not reach the American artists who earned them [source].
This dispute highlights how copyright policy has merged with trade policy. The immediate backdrop is the 2020 Court of Justice of the European Union decision confirming American performers’ entitlement to equitable remuneration, which most EU states subsequently codified [source]. Organizations like IMPALA, representing European independent record companies, now argue that European performers should not share royalties with Americans when the U.S. offers no comparable right to Europeans [source].
Why the Radio Loophole Matters Overseas
The irony is stark: supporters of the American Music Fairness Act have long argued the U.S. terrestrial radio loophole unfairly denies American performers compensation at home [source]. Now, that same loophole is cited overseas as justification to deny compensation to American performers abroad [source]. The coalition urges the Administration to oppose the European proposal as a trade matter, identifying the passage of the American Music Fairness Act as the most direct way to eliminate the rationale for Europe’s policy shift [source].
The bill would create parity across all music platforms by requiring AM/FM broadcasters to compensate artists at fair market rates, while protecting small and community broadcasters with exemptions allowing qualifying stations to pay as little as $10 per year. It establishes a public performance right for sound recordings on terrestrial radio, unlocking hundreds of millions of dollars in overseas royalties currently collected but never paid to American artists. With an identical bill already heard in the House and Senate introduction moving Congress closer to action, the industry’s unified message is clear: American creators must continue receiving the same treatment in Europe that European countries provide their own [source].
For editorial consideration and industry coverage inquiries, contact Radio Facts.
